The Fed Giveth and The Fed Taketh Away
Up-and-down action from yesterday’s Fed talk
![](https://link.mail.beehiiv.com/ss/o/8yDfBWWx3BWicjdd7YBtXw/41p/x32W8uhBQa6pDtgtOYewVw/ho.gif)
Follow @MrTopStep on Twitter and please share if you find our work valuable!
Our View
I know that I sometimes get overly concerned, but I assure you it’s not just for me. I worry about the dollar and interest rates, and more importantly, what this is going to look like for my 29-year-old daughter and her 3-year-old baby in 10 or 20 years.
I was raised in an Irish Catholic family with six girls and four boys. Growing up, I liked playing sports, and believe it or not I was a very good left-handed catcher and an excellent swimmer. I was raised that you “don’t hit girls” and that only by going to school could you better yourself. That second part all changed when Riley Printing Company went out of business.
I was graduating from high school and had plans to go to college, but I couldn’t put that further financial stress on my dad so I headed down to the trading floors of the CBOT and CME.
While I beat out the well-educated guys on the floor from JPMorgan, Goldman, Citi Bank, Merrill Lynch, and others, I still look back and ask myself what if I had gone to Notre Dame like my dad and my brother?
I had no problems getting into hedge funds and banks, but I always wonder if I would have gone further if I had a degree. I know, I know…a degree does not mean you are going to be successful. Somehow though, the educational part — or lack thereof — is what pushed me to work harder than the other guys. When things went bad at my S&P desk, I worked harder.
To summarize, we all have been dealt a hand of cards. We get to choose where we go in life; do we do it sitting down or do we fight? Like the PitBull always says, if you want to make the money, you gotta do the work.
Our Lean
There was only one time in nearly 40 years on the trading floor when we heard a market-related story or rumor that worked.
A guy by the name of Bert G called my S&P desk and told us there was going to be a surprise rate cut tomorrow. Of course, we called it BS, but lo and behold the next day the Fed lowered rates by 0.25% and the markets took off.
While we called it BS, I did tell a few people — one of which was a $22 billion fund. After the Fed’s surprise cut, they were calling me and asking if I could get more info “like that” …lol.
The story was that Bert G traded through Bear Stearns and he was friends with Ace Greenberg, the long-time head of the firm. And this brings me to my point, remember Goldman said they had $7 billion to sell at the end of November? Well, that’s changed to November Pension Fund ME (30Nov) – GS estimates -$9B worth of supply equity for month-end vs. bonds to buy.
The moral of the story is you can’t believe anything you hear!
Our Lean: The ES has been back and filling in a 30-point range for the past few sessions. Our lean is to buy a lower open or buy pullbacks. That doesn’t preclude selling a rip, but I’m long the ES still and looking for higher prices. Yesterday the bonds traded up to the highest they have been since the low on Nov 10th. Get past today’s GDP number and the ES should target the stops above 4585.50.
For those of you who like HandelStats levels, here they are:
-
Upside: Trade and hourly close above 4584.50 targets 1 sd near 4588.64. Hourly close above there targets 4597.73 to 4599. Hourly close above there targets 2 sd at 4613.03. Hourly close above there targets 4622.25 to 4625.25. Hourly close above there targets 4637.43.
-
Downside: Trade and hourly close below 4584.50 targets 4580.50, then 4577.12, then 4569.75. Hourly close below there targets 4:15 settlement at 4564.25. Hourly close below there targets 4556.74, then 4551.75. Hourly close below there targets -1 sd at 4539.86. Hourly close below there targets 4520.50, then -2 sd at 4517.47.
MiM and Daily Recap
The ES traded down to 4547.00 on Globex, overnight inventory was 81% short, and opened Tuesday’s regular session at 4555.25. After the open, the ES traded 4556.75, made a 4549.25 double bottom at 10:00, rallied up to 4557.50 at 10:29, and ripped up to 4566.75 at 10:43 after this headline hit the tape: “FED’S WALLER: IF INFLATION CONSISTENTLY DECLINES “NO REASON” TO INSIST RATES REMAIN “REALLY HIGH.”
After that, the ES down-ticked, traded up to 4577.25 at 11:47 and then another Fed headline came out saying, “FED’S BOWMAN: BASELINE OUTLOOK IS THAT US CENTRAL BANK WILL NEED TO INCREASE INTEREST RATES FURTHER TO KEEP POLICY SUFFICIENTLY RESTRICTIVE.”
From there, the ES sold off down to 4551.75 at 1:02. After the drop, the ES back-and-filled around the VWAP, rallied up to 4563.75 at 3:02 and then sold off down to 4554.00 at 3:24 as the early imbalance showed $103 million to sell. The ES rallied back up to the 4552.25 level at 3:49 and traded and 4564.50 as the 3:50 cash imbalance showed $3.4 billion to buy, traded 4563.75 on the 4:00 cash close and settled at 4564, up 2 points or 0.04% on the day.
In the end, I knew the risk of saying sell the rallies when the ES was down on Globex, and today that meant a lot of low-volume chop. This is what I posted in the MrTopStep chat near the lows of the day.
-
IMPRO: Dboy :(10:15:59 AM): 7 ES buy imbalances, 1.3k ES bought
-
IMPRO: Dboy :(10:16:28 AM): ES still holding in the back and fill pattern, check it out the ES 5 points off the low of the day.
In terms of the ES’s overall tone, it was all about buying weakness. In terms of the ES’s overall trade, volume was a little better: 203k traded on Globex and 1.176 million traded on the day session for a total of 1.379 million contracts traded.
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4f3d5ced-8615-4b11-9a34-63136a1e6eef/Screen_Shot_2023-11-29_at_9.02.08_AM.png?t=1701266846)
Technical Edge
-
NYSE Breadth: 60% Upside Volume
-
Nasdaq Breadth: 61% Upside Volume
-
Advance/Decline: 50% Advance
-
VIX: ~12.50
ES
Levels from HandelStats.com
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/97c5c06e-889f-4a15-a635-17406b8ed079/ES1__2023-11-29_08-54-08.png?t=1701266940)
ES Daily
-
Upside: Trade and hourly close above 4584.50 targets 1 sd near 4588.64. Hourly close above there targets 4597.73 to 4599. Hourly close above there targets 2 sd at 4613.03. Hourly close above there targets 4622.25 to 4625.25. Hourly close above there targets 4637.43.
-
Downside: Trade and hourly close below 4584.50 targets 4580.50, then 4577.12, then 4569.75. Hourly close below there targets 4:15 settlement at 4564.25. Hourly close below there targets 4556.74, then 4551.75. Hourly close below there targets -1 sd at 4539.86. Hourly close below there targets 4520.50, then -2 sd at 4517.47.
NQ
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/46b484f6-bbbe-42be-9327-261bbb43aeb4/NQ1__2023-11-29_08-54-12.png?t=1701266940)
NQ Daily
-
Upside: Trade and hourly close above 16144.75 targets 1 sd at 16184.7. Trade and hourly close above there targets 16284.25, then 16297.71, then 2 sd at 16317.75. Hourly close above there targets 3 sd at 16450.75.
-
Downside: Trade and hourly close below 16144.75 targets 16110, then 16075.25. Hourly close below there targets 4:15 settlement 16051.75. Hourly close below there targets 16012.3, then 15971 then 15947. Hourly close below there targets -1 sd at 15918.75. Below there targets 15902.40, then 15893.75. Hourly close below there targets 15834, hourly close below there targets -2 sd at 15785.75.
Guest Post
PTG / Taylor 3-Day Cycle
Author: David D Dube’ (a.k.a. PTGDavid)
Prior Session was Cycle Day 2 (CD2): Two-way traffic consolidation continued within prior DTS 11.28.23 outlined parameters of 4555 – 4575 edges. Prior range was 30 handles on 1.382M contracts exchanged.
…Transition from Cycle Day 2 to Cycle Day 3
This leads us into Cycle Day 3 (CD3): Three-Day Cycle Statistic will be fulfilled as long as price trades above CD1 Low (4552). This cycle continues to have upside potential targeting 4593 handle. As such, scenarios to consider for today’s trading.
Bull Scenario: Price sustains a bid above 4565, initially targets 4590 – 4595 zone.
Bear Scenario: Price sustains an offer below 4565, initially targets 4540 – 4535 zone.
PVA High Edge = 4565 PVA Low Edge = 4554 Prior POC = 4564
*****The 3 Day Cycle has a 91% probability of fulfilling Positive Cycle Statistics covering 12 years of recorded tracking history.
For more detailed information for both bullish and bearish projected targets, please visit: PTG 3 Day Cycle and/or reference the Cycle Spreadsheet below:
Link to access full Cycle Spreadsheet > > Cycle Day 3 (CD3)
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0f248395-c42b-4596-a263-144fcdae7c30/CD3-1024x231.jpg?t=1701266872)
Thanks for reading,
PTGDavid
PTG Subscriptions:
Economic Calendar
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/1453f6d1-5947-476d-8edd-b8d3421b3e59/Screen_Shot_2023-11-29_at_9.01.21_AM.png?t=1701266889)
Disclaimer: Charts and analysis are for discussion and education purposes only. I am not a financial advisor, do not give financial advice and am not recommending the buying or selling of any security.
Remember: Not all setups will trigger. Not all setups will be profitable. Not all setups should be taken. These are simply the setups that I have put together for years on my own and what I watch as part of my own “game plan” coming into each day. Good luck!
Update your email preferences or unsubscribe here
© 2023 The Opening Print
228 Park Ave S, #29976, New York, New York 10003, United States
No responses yet