This post goes out as an email to our subscribers every day and is posted for free here around 2 PM ET. To get your real-time copy, sign up for the free or premium version here: Opening Print Subscribe.
Nasdaq-Dow Rotation: Billions in Motion and Market Trends
Follow @MrTopStep on Twitter and please share if you find our work valuable!
Our View
The sell YM, buy NQ rotation has been one of the largest rotations I’ve seen since last summer. Yesterday, the NQ surged 1.6% to a new record high, while the YM dropped to new lows. To get a clearer picture of this rotation, I asked @HandleStats to break down the numbers, and it’s quite amazing.
November Market Recap & December Trends
S&P 500 E-mini Futures (ESZ):
-
November saw a strong performance, with ESZ futures gaining 5.45%.
-
For December, they are currently up 0.48%.
Nasdaq 100 E-mini Futures (NQZ):
-
NQZ futures rose 4.85% in November.
-
Today, they achieved a new all-time high, finishing up 5.32% for the month.
Dow Jones E-mini Futures (YMZ):
-
YMZ futures were the standout performer in November, gaining 7.41%.
-
However, December has been less favorable, with futures currently down -2.86% and off -3.30% from the all-time high reached earlier this month.
In a major development, Nvidia (NVDA) officially joined the Dow Jones Index on November 4, 2024, marking a significant milestone for the tech giant.
Nvidia (NVDA):
-
NVDA surged 15.16% from its October close to a November high of $152.89.
-
It closed November up 4.14%.
-
December initially saw NVDA rally 6%, but the stock has since reversed and is now down -10.6% from its December peak.
Basically, the ES has been the odd man out in December, while billions are moving between the Nasdaq and Dow. How long will this last? I don’t know, but had I bought the NQ versus the ES, the numbers speak for themselves.
Our Lean
Bitcoin is up to 1007, yields are down, and oil fell -0.80%. This all seems to be part of the Fed “painting the tape” ahead of the expected rate cut on Wednesday.
Our lean is to buy the pullbacks. I can’t rule out selling a rip, but with all the back-and-fill action, I still believe there is upside.
I did it my way…
I never knew when I walked on the CBOT that my journey would lead me to build the largest S&P 500 futures and options desk on the CME, nor did I know I would have to fight the floor gangs, or what they called broker groups. I was a young Irish scrapper that could not show fear. If there were 4,000 people on the floor, at least 40% of them worked for the groups, and the other 60% loathed these groups. If they spoke out against the brokers, they would not trade with the independent traders; they would literally get shut out. For years, perfectly honest seat owners and traders sat by while the crooks got the cream of the crop trades, while the rest of the pit got the scraps.
I wonder how many thousands of honest, talented traders never made it because of the criminal element that existed? They ran the membership department, the pits were overseen by a pit committee, and the president of the exchange was Jack Sandor, who was partners with the head of ABS broker group, one of the largest broker groups on the floor. When I would get a big new account, the desk phone would ring, and it was Jimmy Kaluentis or his secretary demanding I go to his office to force me to give them the business. I could have taken kickbacks, but I knew that would compromise the trading desk.
When the guy I worked for sent me to the CME, I had been warned, but not in a million years would I have known the level of corruption. It didn’t take long for me to see that the guys at the desk were complicit. Buy 100 ESU (50k a point), and the pit is showing 350.10 bid at 350.20, and the clerk in the pit is yelling, ‘50 lots offered at 20.’ I say, “Buy 100 up to 350.30!” An honest broker would fill the order, but they were far and few between. Instead, the order would get filled up to 350.50, with most of the contracts filled on the high ticks, costing the account uncountable amounts of money.
I remember when Paul Tudor Jones called me at the desk and said he was in town and wanted to meet at Lake Point Tower. The broker Jimmy Place, or AACW, was all excited and picked me up in his limo, and off we went to LPT. After we got there, Paul asked me how I was, and then turned around and said, “Jimmy, please come over here with the several charts and time and sales.” I knew what was coming: all the front-running on the Tudor orders, and it was absolutely despicable. Millions and millions of dollars stolen, and most of it through one broker—I’ll call him MA. Every 300 and 500 lot cost millions in slippage. I knew MA was doing that, but not to that degree. I felt embarrassed and ashamed. After we left, Jimmy asked me if I thought Paul would use the desk again. I remember chuckling, and he got pissed and said, “Answer the question.” I said, “Jimmy, I don’t need to answer the question. Would you?”
Before the open, I called Paul on his cell phone, and he picked up. He said, “What can I do for you, Danny? What can I do for you?” I told him how bad I felt and that I was resigning at the end of the day. He already knew about my run-ins with the broker groups, and he said, “Danny, I don’t blame you. I have heard too many stories about you fighting the brokers.” That was in 1987, and within weeks, I started my own desk. From that moment on, I was attacked at my desk, threatened, told not to take my family on my boat, and warned to watch out for a gas can through my front window. And you know what? It only made me tougher, more pissed, and more determined.
The shake-downs went on for years; they never stopped. Even the compliance department would charge me for things I didn’t do. One investigation went on for years, that I front-ran an order for the PitBull hedge fund. They went through all of his accounts, searched up and down, and found nothing.
To me, it didn’t matter if it was a 1 lot, a 10 lot or a 200 lot, it was someone’s money, and if I had to do it all over again I would not change a thing.
MiM and Daily Recap
ESH25
ESZ25
The ES came into the morning with an overnight low of 6051.50 and an upward drift to 6076.75 before the open, leaving little opportunity for shorts to cover. The regular session opened at 6072.50, and the market made a couple of moves expanding the range, making a slight new high of 6079.25 at 10:04 a.m. before a sell program pushed it down to a session low of 6065 at 10:20 a.m.
Following this low, the ES executed a V-bottom move straight back up, hitting a new session high at 6083.25 by 10:36 a.m. The next hour saw some back-and-fill action before a false breakdown at 6076.75 at 11:44 a.m. marked the beginning of a slow and steady grind higher, driven by accumulation in the NQ.
The ES pushed to a new session high of 6090.50, then moved sideways making a double top at 3:12 p.m. This was followed by a late-day reversal triggered by a sell program, which pushed the market back down to the open. The ES printed 6078 just four minutes before the 3:50 p.m. MiM release, which proved to be some front-running as the imbalances showed $4.8 billion to sell.
This dropped the ES a bit further down to 6073 as the sell imbalance was absorbed and we had some short covering into the cash close to 6081.75. Post-market saw a slight drift lower, and the ES settled at 6076.50, up 25.25 points (+0.41%). The NQ settled at 22,111.75, up 351.25 points (+1.61%), setting another new all-time high closing price.
In the end, the ES finally bounced. The NQ has rallied 1,366 (+6.5%) points in December and the Dow closed down for the eighth session in a row. In terms of the ES’s overall tone, it was firm, the leader remains the tech sector. In terms of the ES’s overall trade, volume was lower at 1.2 million contracts traded against the Z and H.
Technical Edge
Market Levels:
-
Fair Values for December 17th, 2024
-
SP: 77.73
-
NQ: 308.9
-
Dow: 520.53
-
-
Daily Breadth Data 📊
-
NYSE Breadth: 37% Upside Volume
-
Nasdaq Breadth: 69% Upside Volume
-
Total Breadth: 66% Upside Volume
-
NYSE Advance/Decline: 39% Advance
-
Nasdaq Advance/Decline: 50% Advance
-
Total Advance/Decline: 46% Advance
-
NYSE New Highs/New Lows: 82 / 132
-
Nasdaq New Highs/New Lows: 215 / 237
-
NYSE TRIN: 1.07
-
Nasdaq TRIN: 0.44
-
-
Weekly Breadth Data 📈
-
NYSE Breadth: 40% Upside Volume
-
Nasdaq Breadth: 52% Upside Volume
-
Total Breadth: 47% Upside Volume
-
NYSE Advance/Decline: 26% Advance
-
Nasdaq Advance/Decline: 32% Advance
-
Total Advance/Decline: 30% Advance
-
NYSE New Highs/New Lows: 237 / 141
-
Nasdaq New Highs/New Lows: 497 / 359
-
NYSE TRIN: 1.48
-
Nasdaq TRIN: 0.85
-
Room Summaries
Polaris Trading Group Summary – Monday, December 16 2024
Morning Session:
-
The day started with a focus on contract rollovers: ES to the March (H) contract and Crude Oil to February (G).
-
ES saw a bullish scenario early on, targeting 6140–6145, which was achieved quickly. Price maintained a bid above 6130 as anticipated.
-
PTGDavid noted the CL (Crude Oil) long entry at 70.99, and Target 1 was successfully fulfilled at 71.09.
-
Later, the NQ Open Range breakout hit its 1st target, signaling a strong morning for directional trades.
-
The market held a “buy lean” with price activity mostly within the prior session’s range. Bulls were challenged to push through 6155 on ES to expand higher.
Key Trades and Insights:
-
PTGDavid highlighted a perfect reclaim (PKB) of the NQ VWAP, providing an opportunity for long entries.
-
ES eventually cleared and reclaimed 6155 (a prior swing high), with the first pullback offering a clean retest at 54s before continuing higher.
-
Both the morning session and NQ Open Range trades delivered solid results, aligning with the day’s bullish bias.
Afternoon Session:
-
The pace slowed initially, described as a “slow and steady grind higher.”
-
ES continued to climb, expanding the range above the prior swing high (6155), reinforcing bullish control.
-
Near the end of the session, a late-day pullback occurred, attributed to a $5 billion MOC sell imbalance related to mid-month rebalancing.
-
Price settled back into the VWAP zone, providing a clean conclusion to the day’s movement.
End-of-Day Notes:
-
PTGDavid highlighted the positive 3-Day Cycle, maintaining a strong 92.68% streak.
-
A new cycle begins tomorrow, with expectations for a possible decline, signaling a shift to watch closely.
Key Lessons Learned:
-
Reclaiming Levels: The importance of observing prominent levels like VWAP and prior highs was reinforced, particularly the reclaim at 6155 in ES and the PKB setup in NQ.
-
Targets Fulfilled: Staying disciplined with clear targets (CL at 71.09, NQ Open Range breakout, and ES swing high clears) demonstrated the power of trade alignment.
-
End-of-Day Awareness: Understanding mid-month rebalances and MOC imbalances provided context for the late-day price action.
A strong trading day overall, with several profitable opportunities and clear technical alignment. Well done!
Discovery Trading Group Room Preview – December 17, 2024
-
Big Tech Rally:
Tech heavyweights Alphabet (GOOG), Tesla (TSLA), Amazon (AMZN), Apple (AAPL), and Broadcom (AVGO) all closed at record highs. The Nasdaq 100 rose 1.3%, while the S&P 500 climbed 0.4%. However, the Dow Jones dropped 0.2%, marking its 8th consecutive losing session.
-
Fed Rate Decision – Key Focus:
Markets anticipate a 25-basis point rate cut tomorrow with a 97% probability (FedWatch). Attention will be on the Fed dot plot—previously signaling 4 rate cuts in 2025—which may be revised to 3 due to robust economic data, a tight labor market, and persistent inflation. Markets may enter a “wait mode” after this morning’s economic releases.
-
Healthcare Sector Hit:
Healthcare stocks CVS, UnitedHealth (UNH), and Cigna (CI) fell following comments from President-elect Trump about targeting pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), accused of inflating drug prices. -
MicroStrategy Joins Nasdaq 100:
MicroStrategy (MSTR) surged Monday as it prepares to join the Nasdaq 100, replacing Super Micro Computer Inc. (SMCI), which fell on the news. MicroStrategy is shifting focus from software to bitcoin investments.Walmart Named Yahoo Finance’s 2024 Company of the Year:
Walmart (WMT) achieved four quarters of record earnings, outperforming rivals. Investments in AI, AR, same-day delivery, and lower prices have driven WMT shares up 82% this year. The $2.3 billion acquisition of Vizio enhances targeted advertising capabilities. -
Key Economic Calendar:
-
Retail Sales at 8:30 AM ET
-
Capacity Utilization & Industrial Production at 9:15 AM ET
-
Business Inventories & NAHB Housing Index at 10:00 AM ET
Market Trends & Levels (ES Futures):
-
Volatility: Flat; 5-day average range ~43 points.
-
Channels: Short-term uptrend support at 6111/14; resistance at 6270/75 and 6281/86.
-
A break of 6111/14 could trigger significant bearish momentum, while bulls maintain room to defend trendlines.
Other Notes:
No significant corporate earnings today. Overnight large trader volume was light. -
ES – Week over Week
We flipped to the H25 contract yesterday. 750K traded on the Z25 vs 460K on the H24. Time to switch. ES continues to trade in its tight little pennant. If ES wants to run higher, we think it does, we would expect to see a push to the 6193 level with the next stop at 6234. On the downside, a mood swing could start with a break of 6108. A trend switch will not happen until 5990, we are at the top of the trading range and not moving much.
NQ – Week over Week
NQ continues to push higher. Top side today looking at 22,751. A close above 22,333 will consolidate this push. Support is 21,952 and the trend reversal for us for today is 21,495.
Economic Calendar
Important Recent and Upcoming Events
Earnings Today:
Affiliate Disclosure: This newsletter may contain affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. This comes at no additional cost to you and helps us continue providing valuable content. We only recommend products or services we genuinely believe in. Thank you for your support!
Disclaimer: Charts and analysis are for discussion and education purposes only. I am not a financial advisor, do not give financial advice and am not recommending the buying or selling of any security.
Remember: Not all setups will trigger. Not all setups will be profitable. Not all setups should be taken. These are simply the setups that I have put together for years on my own and what I watch as part of my own “game plan” coming into each day. Good luck!
This post goes out as an email to our subscribers every day and is posted for free here around 2 PM ET. To get your real-time copy, sign up for the free or premium version here: Opening Print Subscribe.
Comments are closed